redo of 1 of my old maps called mnhpolterv6

[macanah]

hi there
macanah here
here is a redo of map i made called mnhdmpolterv6
much better looking than the last 1
neway have fun
tell me what u think about it if u choose

my site = www.freewill-mnh.com

[Deleted]

comments:

One year ago you release a new map, i view/played your map..
write some nicy comments,advice how to improve your map in Quark,
Unfortunately you ignored, no respond at all,
two weeks later you opened a new thread and release another remake or a redo, and so on...
You`re not a newbie in mapping already released eight maps..

I myself have ( many ) map sketches on my hdd drive,yeah unfinished maps,not good enough for public release.
Your map (in these circumstances) must remain on your hard disk..
fact is, your map is not finish...( that is my opinion )..

I map with a purpose,for a good cause, try bring new life in this fifteen year old game.
that`s my duty as an amateur author.

Sooo Macanah..
I have a question for you, WHY release such unfinished Quake2 map??.

[Crypt]

hi there

macanah here

here is a redo of map i made called mnhdmpolterv6

much better looking than the last 1

The effort is much appreciated, I will give you that.

Posted by Margaal6 hours ago


I map with a purpose,for a good cause, try bring new life in this fifteen year old game. 
that`s my duty as an amateur author.



Sooo Macanah..

I have a question for you, WHY release such unfinished Quake2 map??.

Ok, first off, if you put it out there for the public to see, then I'm going to assume your a big enough boy to take the heat in whatever form it comes at you.

I gotta go with Margaal on this one bro, I was on and off the map in under 45 secs, it really doesn't appear as though you were mapping with a purpose. I can appreciate that you love the game and that you want to make maps for it,  ..however if you are looking for an honest opinion this map at the stage its at does not do the game any justice at all. 

I have been spending hours upon hours studying maps in detail since my return, literally I have looked at over 8000 + maps. As I have mentioned, mapping was not my thing back in the day, I played the maps bro and I played them hard, ..from the standpoint of a hardcore player, this map does not cut it. 

I get it, if your working on your own/choose to work on your own, learn everything on your own with out a mentor yada yada yada blippity blah blah but the next time you sit down and decide you want to create a map. I want you to stick this in the fore front of your mapping thought process and that is this, " I macanah am a "Quake player, Doom player, whatever player" and I am mapping for the community and before the community I will be judged but I must be able to judge myself" <-- Some what philosophical but there is a point to it, I hope you see it.

I applaud your courage, keep mapping and don't be afraid to keep sharing your maps. Its a new era in the Quake world macanah, if you want to get noticed, this was not the way to do it my friend.


Attachment Deleted